Providence Rag Page 25

  Lomax had long ago taught himself to read the backwards-flowing type. Just before midnight, he climbed up on a press and squinted at the page-one plate, making sure the last minute fixes he’d sent to the composing room had been made in time for the first-edition press run. Then he returned to the newsroom and checked the final edits on the videos before hitting the computer button to post them, along with Mason’s story, on the newspaper’s Web site.

  The six videos proving that Diggs had assaulted no one on October 20, 2011, had been edited into a single four-minute segment. The ninety-second video of Diggs’s poem about blondes, included to supplement the story’s assessment of his character, was preceded by a warning about “violent and sexual content.”

  Earlier that day, Lomax sat down with Mason to explain the decisions he’d made when he edited the story.

  “I left in the stuff about how the 2005 assault might have been fabricated,” he said. “Your reporting on that isn’t conclusive, but it’s strong enough to suggest a pattern of official misconduct.”

  “Good,” Mason said.

  “But I cut out the stuff about how Diggs may have been framed for the drug charge. You’re probably right about that, too, but the reporting isn’t strong enough to hold up.”

  “I disagree,” Mason said.

  “I don’t care what you think,” Lomax snapped.

  “You’re the boss,” Mason said.

  “Look,” Lomax said, softening a little. “Mulligan is right about this. A guard could have circumvented security and brought Diggs the drugs. You know what’s at stake here, Mason. We can’t afford to get anything wrong. You should be happy we’re printing any of this at all.”

  “Okay.”

  “And Mason? It would be best if you don’t come in tomorrow. A lot of people are going to be furious at us. With your byline on the story, it might not be safe.”

  At one A.M., Lomax felt the newsroom floor shudder as the presses roared to life. He took the elevator down to the mailroom and snatched one of the first copies to roll off the press. The ink on the seventy-two-point, second-coming headline was still wet.

  Diggs Framed on Assault Charge

  Beneath the headline, a smaller subhead:

  Official Misconduct Could Force Killer’s Release

  The managing editor tucked the Sunday newspaper under his left arm, made his way to the lobby, and strode out the Dispatch’s front door. There, three square-jawed behemoths, each squeezed into a blue uniform that looked a size too small, stood watch. Five more Wackenhut security guards, hired by the publisher for the occasion, were stationed at other points around the building. Each was equipped with pepper spray and a billy club.

  Lomax drove home, cracked open a fresh bottle of Scotch, and sipped from it all night, too agitated to sleep.

  63

  At seven o’clock on Monday morning, Mulligan grabbed a breakfast sandwich and coffee to go at Charlie’s diner and ambled past the old Biltmore Hotel toward the Dispatch. When he reached Fountain Street, he saw that the newspaper’s windows had been reinforced with masking tape.

  He stopped to watch two Providence cops order Iggy Rock to move WTOP’s mobile broadcast van from an illegal parking spot across from the newspaper’s front door. The van swung around Burnside Park and claimed two metered spaces next to Union Station, a 114-year-old yellow-brick train station that had been converted to house an array of offices, pubs, and retail shops. From there, Iggy had a good view of the street in front of the newspaper.

  As Mulligan reached the Dispatch’s front door, he saw Gloria trotting down the sidewalk. He waited for her, and together they flashed their newspaper IDs at the Wackenhut guards. They entered the lobby and took the elevator upstairs to the newsroom. There they found Lomax already at his desk, two empty newsroom vending machine coffee cups in front of him and a fresh one in his hand.

  “Mulligan,” Lomax said, “you’ll be writing the protest story. That means monitoring Iggy Rock’s broadcast, checking with the circulation department on cancellations, and watching the street activity from the roof.”

  “The roof? I should be on the street.”

  “No way. This means you, too, Gloria. You can get all the photos we need from there. The story’s not worth either of you getting hurt.”

  “Okay, boss,” she said.

  “And keep away from the windows today,” Lomax added.

  By seven thirty, the telephones in the circulation department were ringing off the hook. Mulligan spent a half hour listening to a dozen clerks try to talk angry readers out of canceling the paper. He asked a few of them what the callers were saying and got a bunch of quotes, most of them unprintable. Then he returned to his desk, snapped on a radio Lomax had placed there, and listened to Iggy rant about the “criminal-loving left-wing extremist Dispatch.” The host urged his listeners to mass in front of the paper for the day’s protest.

  At nine A.M., Mulligan joined Gloria on the flat, tar-paper roof. The crowd on the sidewalk across the street had swelled to about four hundred people, some carrying signs reading “Screw the Dispatch” and “Cancel Your Subscription.” As the crowd spilled into the roadway, Providence police cruisers blocked off Fountain Street. A hundred yards to the north, thirty cops massed Burnside Park.

  By noon, the crowd reached a peak of eight hundred people by Mulligan’s estimate. They had been chanting off and on all morning. Sometimes, “Screw the Dispatch.” Sometimes, “What are you thinking?” A few tossed eggs that broke against the newspaper’s red-brick walls and splattered the uniforms of the Wackenhuts.

  “They’re so angry,” Gloria said.

  “And scared,” Mulligan said.

  The day was hot and humid, the tar paper sticky under Mulligan’s Reeboks. Gloria’s arms were turning red. She dropped the camera, letting it hang by its strap from her neck, and smeared on some sunscreen.

  Shortly after one P.M., two young men broke from the crowd, crow-hopped toward the building, and threw baseball-size rocks. One caromed off the brick, bounced off the sidewalk, and clipped the thigh of a woman protester. From the roof, Mulligan and Gloria heard her shriek. The other rock must have hit a window, because they heard glass shatter.

  Five Wackenhuts bolted from the front steps and charged the rock throwers, two of the guards firing cans of pepper spray and one swinging his billy. The rock throwers fell to the pavement. The crowd surged forward, driving the guards back. The police stood fast in the park, perhaps realizing their intervention would only make things worse. Gloria’s shutter clicked, capturing a bird’s-eye view.

  By two o’clock, storm clouds gathered over the harbor. Gloria looked at the sky and shivered. Thunder boomed, and a bolt of lightning struck the Sportsman’s Inn’s neon sign. It exploded in a shower of sparks as the rain came down hard and heavy.

  Gloria’s shoulders shook. She closed her eyes and began her breathing exercise.

  “Give me the camera,” Mulligan said. “I’ve got this.”

  “I’m okay.”

  “Get your pretty butt inside. The show’s about over for today, anyway.”

  Gloria surrendered her camera and headed for the stairwell.

  Below, the crowd was breaking up. Soon only a dozen stragglers remained, some of them holding umbrellas. Mulligan raised the camera and took a few shots of a nearly deserted street littered with abandoned, rain-soaked protest signs.

  64

  The city’s old retail district, squeezed into four compact blocks between Pine and Fountain Streets, had been crumbling since the 1960s; and after Waterplace Park and the Providence Place Mall were built in the 1990s, all of the action had shifted several blocks north. The early-twentieth-century storefronts that were left behind—the ones that hadn’t been torn down to make way for Johnson & Wales University dormitories—now housed discount liquor stores, bucket-of-blood bars, secondhand shops, palm readers, unlicensed massage parlors, or nothing at all. The governor’s limousine, a state trooper behind the wheel, idled at the
curb in front of Hopes on Washington Street, as out of place as a debutante in a sweatshop.

  Mulligan pushed through the front door and found Fiona waiting for him at a table in back. He grabbed a Killian’s at the bar, wandered over, and dropped into the seat across from her.

  “Thought you weren’t supposed to hang out here anymore,” he said.

  “So my press secretary kept telling me,” she said. “According to him, cheap bottle beer, restrooms with condom dispensers on the walls, and a warped linoleum floor that gets mopped once a week are not in keeping with the image a governor needs to cultivate. This morning, I reminded him that, despite our downtown renaissance, our little city-state is still a working-class bastion, and that this is exactly the image a governor who wants to be reelected should cultivate.”

  “You did?”

  “Yes. Just before I fired him.”

  “You fired him for that?”

  “Not just for that, no.”

  Mulligan whipped out his notepad and said, “Tell me more.”

  When she finished enumerating her former staffer’s deficiencies, Mulligan asked, “Have you named a replacement yet?”

  “I was hoping you might take the job.”

  “Thanks, but no thanks.”

  “It pays twice what you make now—and a lot more than nothing, which is what you’ll be making when the Dispatch goes under.”

  Mulligan held his longneck up to the ceiling light and studied its contents through the amber glass. “If I was going to flack for anybody, it would be you, Fiona, but it’s just not in me to tell lies for a living.”

  “I prefer to think of it as spin.”

  “Same thing. This why you wanted to see me? To offer me a job?”

  “There’s more,” she said, and slid a nine-by-twelve-inch manila envelope across the table. “I thought you might want a look at the psychiatric evaluation of Diggs before Judge Needham’s hearing tomorrow.”

  “What’s the headline?”

  “That he’s fucking nuts.”

  “Crazy enough to be involuntarily committed?”

  “That depends,” Fiona said.

  “On what?”

  “On what Needham cares about more—the legal niceties or his personal safety.”

  * * *

  Reginald Baer, deputy chief of psychiatry at Butler Hospital, sat stiffly in the witness chair, his posture that of a man in need of disk surgery. He wore a navy-and-white polka-dot bow tie and clutched a copy of his report in both hands. Attorney General Roberts paced in front of him, a duplicate rolled in his left fist.

  “If you would,” Roberts was saying, “please tell the court where and when you conducted your psychiatric evaluation of Kwame Diggs.”

  “On July twenty-six, twenty-seven, and thirty at the Corrections Department’s High Security Center in Cranston, Rhode Island.”

  “And how long were these sessions?”

  “Approximately two hours each, for a total of six hours.”

  “Did the inmate cooperate? Did he answer all of your questions willingly?”

  “He did.”

  “Since the court has already had the opportunity to review your written evaluation, I’d like to skip ahead to your conclusions.”

  “Fine.”

  “Did you find that Mr. Diggs is suffering from a mental illness?”

  “I did.”

  “And what is your diagnosis?”

  “Mr. Diggs suffers from bipolar disorder.”

  “And how long has he been bipolar?”

  “It is impossible to say with certainty, but given the answers he provided about his childhood, the onset was probably in his early teens.”

  “Please explain in laymen’s terms what bipolar disorder entails.”

  “Bipolar disorder is often referred to in the vernacular as manic depression. It is characterized by extreme mood swings that range from severe depression to feelings of euphoria. An example many people would be familiar with is John Nash, the Princeton University graduate student portrayed by Russell Crowe in the film A Beautiful Mind.”

  From his seat in the jury box, set aside once again for press, Mulligan saw Roberts wince. In the film, John Nash was a sympathetic figure.

  “Are some bipolar patients more debilitated than others?” Roberts asked.

  “Most certainly.”

  “Please tell us how it has affected Mr. Diggs’s ability to function.”

  “In his case, the condition was accompanied by an inability to develop genuine friendships and intense feelings of resentment toward society. His isolation led him to construct a fantasy world, which, over time, became more real to him than the world the rest of us live in.”

  “Did Mr. Diggs describe this fantasy world to you?”

  “He did. It involved violent daydreams, sometimes accompanied by compulsive masturbation.”

  “Are individuals such as Mr. Diggs likely to cross the line between fantasy and reality and act out their daydreams?”

  “Only rarely.”

  “But in this case, he did?”

  “Yes.”

  “Excuse me,” the judge broke in. “Dr. Baer, you are referring to the murders that Mr. Diggs committed more than a decade ago, is that right?”

  “Yes, Your Honor.”

  “And he has not acted out his daydreams on any occasion since that time, is that correct?”

  “It is, Your Honor, but in prison, he would have had no opportunity to do so.”

  “Thank you. Mr. Roberts, you may proceed.”

  “Dr. Baer,” the attorney general said, “did you find that Mr. Diggs is suffering from any other mental problem?”

  “I did.”

  “And that would be?”

  “Antisocial personality disorder, or ASPD.”

  “Please explain that condition to the court.”

  “Persons with severe ASPD are malignant narcissists. They lack empathy and are typically deceitful, impulsive, manipulative, and incapable of feeling guilt.”

  “In layman’s terms, someone with ASPD would be considered a psychopath, isn’t that correct?”

  “Objection,” Diggs’s lawyer, Felicia Freyer, broke in. “Mr. Roberts is leading the witness.”

  “This is not a criminal trial, Miss Freyer,” the judge said. “Please refrain from unnecessary objections that waste the court’s time. Dr. Baer, you may answer.”

  “Psychopath is not a term I care to use, but it would be the layman’s term, yes.”

  “There are degrees of ASPD, are there not?” Roberts asked, continuing his incessant pacing.

  “There are.”

  “Is there a test for measuring its severity?”

  “Several. I prefer the Hare Psychopathy Checklist, a group of twenty criteria that measure a person’s antisocial behavior on a scale of one to forty.”

  “Did you perform this test on Mr. Diggs?”

  “I did.”

  “And what did you find?”

  “He scored a twenty-six.”

  “I see. And what would be an average score in the general population?”

  “Four.”

  “So Kwame Diggs’s score was nearly seven times normal?”

  “Six point five times, to be precise.”

  From the jury box, Mulligan saw that Freyer was furiously scribbling notes.

  “In your opinion, Doctor,” Roberts said, “is Mr. Diggs in need of inpatient psychiatric care?”

  “Yes.”

  “And in your opinion, would he be a danger to himself or others if he were to be released without such treatment?”

  “In my medical opinion, he would be, yes.”

  “Thank you, Dr. Baer,” Roberts said. He stopped pacing and took his seat at the prosecution table.

  “Miss Freyer,” the judge said, “do you wish to question the witness?”

  “I certainly do, Your Honor.”

  Her huge glasses were gone today, and her blond hair had been sheared to a gentle swirl that barely brushed
her shoulders. She had hoped to hire her own psychiatric expert, but Mrs. Diggs couldn’t afford it. Nevertheless, the young lawyer appeared confident as she rose to address the witness.

  “Dr. Baer, are you saying that my client is a psychopath?”

  “I never used that term.”

  “Forgive me, Doctor. I believe you prefer to call it antisocial personality disorder, is that correct?”

  “It is.”

  “And according to your testimony, my client scored a twenty-six on the Hare test used to diagnose this condition, is that also correct?”

  “Yes.”

  “Are you aware, Doctor, that according to Kent Kiehl and Joshua Buckholtz, who wrote about this condition for Scientific American, a patient is not considered a psychopath unless he scores at least thirty on the test?”

  “Again, I must object to the term psychopath, but I am aware of their work, yes.”

  “Are Kiehl and Buckholtz recognized experts in this area of study?”

  “They are widely considered to be, yes.”

  “Do you agree with their conclusion?”

  The witness hesitated and began fussing with his bow tie.

  “Dr. Baer?”

  “I suppose so, yes.”

  “Is there some reason your report failed to mention that Kwame Diggs’s score on the Hare test was too low for him to be diagnosed—if I may be excused for repeating the term—as a psychopath?”

  “I can only assume that it was omitted in error.”

  “In error?” Freyer said, putting all the incredulity she could muster into the question.

  “Yes.”

  Freyer smirked, shook her head in mock dismay, and consulted her notes.

  “During your evaluation, Doctor, did Mr. Diggs express sympathy for the victims of his crimes?”

  “He did.”

  “On six separate occasions, isn’t that correct?”

  “I would need to review my report to be sure, but that is approximately correct, yes.”

  “Were his expressions of remorse sincere?”

  Again with the bow tie.